Connie’s Classic Thin-Crust Super Pizza Review

Connie’s classic thin-crust pizza is on the plate tonight. We hadn’t seen it in the frozen section until recently, but, the pizza brand has actually been around for a while.

Subscribe to our food YouTube channel!!

It may have just taken its time getting to the upper mid-western state where these reviews happen. Either way, this pizza was highly recommended by my grandpa who’s been buying them left and right lately. That and I was feeling motivated to review some pizza.

They look something like a cross between a Red Baron and DiGiorno pizza. Both of those are pretty solid choices, so naturally, it seemed like this Connie’s could be, too.

Connie’s Classic Thin-Crust: The Company

There’s quite a story behind this pizza. While other pizza brands don’t always mention their history on the box, these guys don’t hold anything back.

There’s even been some crazy stuff with the mafia and Connie’s, believe it or not. They don’t mention that, though. Found it by accident in the ol’ Google machine.

Connie's pizza story
This College Life

The company started back in 1963 when Jim Stolfe sold his ’62 Oldsmobile Starfire for a small storefront pizzeria. That was his first step toward developing a pizza brand that would become iconic in Chicago and in freezer sections all over the place.

Connie’s classic thin-crust is unique – they dust it with cornmeal, put on a signature sauce (family recipe), and add a handful of premium quality toppings.

One thing that I think really signaled the pizza’s freshness was the fact that its expiration date was about five months from the time I bought it. Many products, frozen or otherwise, are good for way longer than that due to all the preservatives.

Nutrition Facts

This pizza might be a thin crust, but it’s not thin on calories. You’ll be looking at 310 for each serving (which is 1/5 of the pizza) and 1550 for the entire thing. Each serving packs 20% of your daily amount of recommended calcium and 10% of your daily amount of iron.

Eating the entire thing in one sitting might be a bit risky since the pizza packs 35% of your daily amount of saturated fat in one serving. It also has 22% of your daily amount of fat per serving.

There’s also a big chunk of sodium for each serving, 34% of your daily value. Eating too little or too much sodium can be problematic for you, so this pizza could be exactly what you need to fill in any salt gaps in your diet.

Connie's classic thin-crust
This College Life


The ingredients for Connie’s classic thin-crust are pretty intense. Mainly because they list the ingredients of everything that goes on the pizza. This includes things like the granulated garlic and degerminated yellow cornmeal.

There’s garlic in a few of the other things, too, like the Italian sausage. Your heart will be glad to hear that there’s no added nitrates in the uncured pepperoni.

It also contains milk, wheat, and soy, so if you can’t handle those, then this isn’t for you. But most pizza does, so that’s not unexpected. Plus, you need at least the milk and wheat for a decent pizza.

Connie’s Classic Thin Crust Cooking Instructions

Connie's classic thin-crust pizza review
This College Life

Pretty standard cooking instructions, you need to pre-heat your oven to 425 degrees Fahrenheit. We went with using a pizza pan instead of a stone or putting it directly on the rack.

Eyeball it for doneness.

The Review

Well, here it is: a Connie’s classic thin-crust review. What we’ve all been waiting for.

*drum roll please*

It’s pretty good. There, I said it. Actually, it’s really tasty. Definitely wasn’t delivered either. This pizza genuinely tasted like it might have come from an Italian restaurant and not my freezer.

The cornmeal dusting on the crust is the bomb, the crust itself actually isn’t that thin, either. To their family, it might be thin, but I’m guessing medium and thick are practically deep-dish style to them.

Your cheese will be thick, same with the other ingredients – sausage, pepperoni, peppers, onions, olives, the whole bit. The pizza was awesome.

Leave Your Own Review of Connie’s Pizza:

The Best Frozen Pizza On The Market!!

Rated 5 out of 5
February 6, 2023

I have tried 2 different types of Connie’s Pizza. Both were thin crust. Delicious!! Because, let’s face it–frozen pizzas have a long way to go in the taste department. Especially vs. Pizzeria pizza. Connie’s, I will gladly buy and eat.

Tom G.

Incredible!! 5 ⭐'s is Not Enough!

Rated 5 out of 5
January 16, 2023

Connie’s Thin Crust Pizza is the BEST frozen pizza I’ve ever had. The sauce, the cheese the toppings (Everything!) SO incredibly Good! It’s Definitely my go to frozen pizza from now on. Five stars is not enough! ❤️❤️⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐



Rated 5 out of 5
January 3, 2023

Our neighbor invited a few others over for 2023 New Years gathering. Connie’s Pizza was one of the items on the table to enjoy. All I can say is this truly is the BEST frozen pizza ever! We had the Supreme/Super. Each ingredient was well represented as not one ingredient was the dominator, which is what you want. Hats off to the chef as they say… I will purchase regardless. Hands down the BEST FROZEN PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD. I am 58. – Raleigh NC 1-03-2023

Chrissie Jaje